Carl Jung and The Value of Anxiety Disorders



Anxiety disorders, or what traditionally have been classified as forms of neuroses, are so prevalent in the modern world that some suggest we live in an age of anxiety. But what is causing so many people to suffer from anxiety disorders? The psychologist Carl Jung spent much of his career trying to answer this question. Jung's theory of neurosis, however, is largely overlooked in our day where pills are seen as the panacea for virtually all mental ailments. But Jung's theory demands our attention because, unlike the pharmaceutical model, which focuses on symptomatic relief, Jung viewed the neurotic illness as signalling to us that change in our way of life is needed. If we merely mask the symptoms and go on with life as usual, then we impoverish ourself, losing access to the crucial information that the neurotic illness provides. In this two part video series, we will provide an overview of Jung's theory. In this first video, we are going to explore what anxiety disorders can teach us about our way of life, by examining what Jung saw as their root cause. In part two, we will discuss how Jung proposed we can escape the clutches of our demons in order to return to a more flourishing way of life. A defining feature of Jung's theory is that the cause of the neurosis is always to be found in the present. As he wrote, Jung was not denying that our neurotic suffering may have started in our childhood, nor was he overlooking the influence our upbringing has on our psychological development. Rather, he focused on the present because he believed that what generated the symptoms of the neurosis was a conflicted way of life in the here and now. Conflicts may have been present in our childhood, but those conflicts have changed and are no longer the source of our present suffering. Or as Jung explained, What is the nature of the conflict that leads to the neurosis? In his essay, "The significance of the father in the destiny of the individual'', Jung provides a quote by the Greek Stoic philosopher Cleanthes which helps unravel this mystery. The Fates were the three weaving goddesses of Greek mythology who spun the threads of individual destiny. Jung did not believe in gods or goddesses determining our fate, but he did believe that each of us is presented with a series of life tasks, which are not of our choosing, and so can be conceptualized as our fate. These tasks are a product of our evolutionary history, our immortal nature, and the culture in which we live. Foremost among these is our biological drive to pass on our genes, but others include the need to achieve psychological independence from our parents, to cultivate a social life, to contribute to our community, to find a purpose, and eventually, to face up to death. According to Jung, we are naturally driven to accomplish these tasks. Our instincts, our nature as social animals, the pull of conformity, and our ever approaching death, all impel us in this direction. But while we are naturally driven to achieve the tasks of life, we also have a tendency towards inertia and self-sabotage, or as Jung put it, If we can get the upper hand on our laziness and display the courage to face up to the tasks of life, then these tasks act as guides, marking the path toward a healthy development. 'Fate leads us forward.' But if our laziness and fear get the upper hand, and we neglect the tasks of life, then they become chains around our neck. We become the unwilling; in the words of Cleanthes, 'whom Fate drags forward.' The neurotic, according to Jung, is the man or woman who walks among the unwilling, who has adopted, in other words, a faulty attitude towards the tasks of life. When treating his patients, Jung emphasized that the problem for the neurotic lies always with their attitude, achievement of the tasks being of secondary importance. For life can present us with immense challenges which make it impossible to achieve a certain task. But this does not destine us to a life of neurotic suffering. In such cases, acceptance of the situation, and a shifting of our energy to another of life's tasks is the appropriate reaction. But usually the obstacles that impede us are not of an insurmountable nature; rather, what holds up back is a moral incapacity. We are either too lazy, or we lack the courage to face up to the challenge. Being impeded in this manner is not unique to the neurotic, as we all face times where our resolve is tested. But what is unique to the neurotic is that, rather than acknowledge their incapacities, they choose to deceive themselves and to lay blame solely on the obstacles in their path, or as Jung explains, In such a conflicted state, our desire to achieve the tasks of life, and all the energy which impels us in this direction, does not simply disappear. Rather, it seeks an alternative outlet, or as Jung explains, In other words, if we cease to moving forward in life, we tend to regress to more immature or what Jung called infantile, modes of adaption. And this regression in the response to the conflict is what generates the various symptoms of the neurosis. Be it the pervasive anxiety, phobias, compulsive behaviors, depression, apathy or obsessive and intrusive thoughts. But as uncomfortable as such symptoms may be, they serve an important purpose, by alerting us to the fact that we are descending down a dangerous life path. For while we regress psychologically, our physical maturation does not cease, and a glance in the mirror forever reminds us that we are not keeping pace with the seasons of life and the inexorable march of time. The longer we exist in this conflicted state, the less adapted we feel, and a vicious cycle takes over whereby When caught in the grips of a neurosis, we are likely to wonder why we were cursed in this way. What led us to react to the challenges of life in this inappropriate manner? Jung did not see a single cause for this incapacity; rather, each case is unique. For some of us it can be blamed on our genes. Certain newborn babies, Jung observed, display a which predisposes them to the neurotic attitude later in life. In other cases, it is a poor upbringing: But for most people it is an indecipherable combination of genetic and environmental influences which is ultimately to blame. Whatever the cause, crucial question is how to break the cycle of our neurotic suffering. If we are willing to acknowledge our conflicted way of life, what can we do to resolve it? In the next video, we'll explore Jung's ideas regarding this question. As we will see, his prescription did not involve digging through the events of our childhood or working through what he called the Rather, Jung maintained that the best way to conquer a neurosis is through the construction of something new. Specifically, a new attitude to life. We must look forward, not back.

43 comments

  1. Become a Supporting Member and gain access to exclusive videos and courses!): https://academyofideas.com/members/
    Join through PayPal or Credit Card (payments processed by Stripe)
    ====
    Find our Recommended Readings on Jung here:
    https://academyofideas.com/store/
    ====
    Access the transcript (and art work) here:
    https://academyofideas.com/2019/01/carl-jung-value-of-anxiety-disorders/
    ====

  2. Ouh, it hurts… And explain why I understand so well memes… So much things to achieve in order to not being depressed anymore!!!
    Thanks for this video

  3. I prefer Freud’s concept that behaviour in the present is invariably governed by memory of past experience.
    If you were bitten by a dog as a child you will have apprehension about dogs as an adult which someone who has never been bitten by a dog does not go through.
    Certainly though dealing with this neurosis may only occur through confronting present day experience.
    The challenge though is still to identify the memory of the past which governs a current behaviour pattern as this will
    assist in changing the pattern in the present.

  4. Anxiety is the new normal. You are being preyed upon by other humans with more money and more power who only care about what you produce. Being neurotic is not being anxious. If neurotic means being deranged then all our leaders are neurotic. Read the Jung Cult by Richard Noll. Jung was as wrong as Freud. Jung was also a dishonest. Only teen boys refer to Jung.

  5. This is Of Immense Help! Sincere Thanks to Everyone who made this Video!! You Have My Eternal Gratitude!!

  6. Me:

    My Brain: YO WAKE UP LOSER ITS YA ABSENT FATHER SKINNY WEENIE YOUR LATE FOR SATURDAY ITS ONLY 4 AM LETS COUNT WALL BUMPS

  7. What about continually dealing with abuse for years & one huge mountain after another. Some now still proving insurmountable & continual negative impacts. Major things where you need physical support but no one can to help.

  8. Jung is spot on in many areas, but to posit that seeking out the cause of a disturbance/tangles is fruitless sounds like dissociation —- it is one thing to get stuck in and dwell on the past, it is quite another to identify from where the damage has originated and to repair it or like Jung says start on a new path—and really it is both/and

  9. Apparently, Mr. Jung didn't think to wed Absurdist philosophy to Buddhism to the main themes of The Border Trilogy. Silly Goose.

    I'll listen anyway.

  10. So demons but doesn't believe in God…you can't have one without the other…Without up there is no down, without light there is no darkness…or how would u know…enjoy

  11. It seems both Adler and Jung doesn't agree with Freud. Freud seems to have implanted (absurd imo)ideas that are now ingrained in the western culture like the Oedipus complex and the obsession with the past/childhood experiences.

  12. "The Fates lead the willing, but drag the unwilling."
    Cleanthes

    This makes me realize the levels at which humans since "very long ago" were capable of reaching, and how unalterable are certain truths regardless of how different the times seem.

  13. The idea of the predestined life task is nothing but secularized paganism. The only purpose of life is salvation, and that is in Christ, who is the Son of the God who gave us free will.

    Said imma be a SEXY BOSS, then imma be a SEXY BOSS.

    Do not mix providence with fatalism.
    Fatalism is a sin as defined by the Catholic Church.

    Lastly, to quote Alexander Pope:

    "In life's vast ocean diversely we sail.
    Reason the card, but passion is the gale."

  14. What I've drawn as a conclusion is that what so-called healers digging into our emotions to allegedly cure us seem to be just scams to feed their own feeling of importance.

  15. Start with Vitamin D insufficiency / deficiency, normally made by sun light touching skin, if we cover up or live our lives indoors we are then relying on diet. Dairy products and meat are then key sources, Vegans need then to take seriously a likelihood of Vit D shortage. Anxiety and depression are on the spectrum of Vit D insufficiency. Interesting that Swedish Dog walkers have been (research) found to be happier than the average (Swede) – of course unconditional companionship, regular exercise, yes but outside, you mean in the sun if you don't mind, is that where we have got to in this conversation…

Leave a Reply

(*) Required, Your email will not be published